DISQUS

Tom · 1 year ago

Not so dumb and dumber

kiley · 1 year ago

thanks Tom B! now i don't feel so bad about my awful awful taste in bad comedies that have no intellectual or substantial merit! ;) (but i do so love Dumb and Dumber, it can't be helped!)

Phil · 1 year ago

I love Dumb & Dumber.

Also saw Step Brothers this weekend, which I got a laugh out of despite poor reviews.

I'm glad you brought up this movie, because I would like to hear Jett (Maestro) & the Good Prof. Dr. review a pure comedy on this show at some point (not sure if they have before?), just to see what their sensibilities are when it comes to humor (or, for Prof. Dr.: "humour") and what they deem makes a good comedy (just laughs or must it have production value as well?).

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

Comedy Comedy Comedy

kiley · 1 year ago

these conversation trees are getting confusing, LOL! i get where the replies are coming in at, each reply is indented from the one above it, but the main ones are coming in 'backards' - so, the newest replies are at the top and it descends from there?

Phil · 1 year ago

I guess what I mean is - you and Gareth seem to do a great job at breaking down different themes within a movie, or how it's shot, or it's overall plot, etc. etc.....so that's why I wonder, in a comedy, would either or both of you view it on laughs alone, or would you be more critical of the overall movie itself in terms of all the technical aspects or aesthetics whathaveyou that you guys have an eye for.

I just haven't heard you review one, so I'm not sure how you'd look at it from a critical standpoint.

& 'Mummymia'.....hilarious.

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

As long as it works

Tom · 1 year ago

Hi Gareth,

Your new post really struck a cord with me. Some films are indeed like comfort food or favourite music. Maybe this is how you tell a true lover of film, if films are a way that we chart our lives. I, like Jett mentioned the other day, have the ability to remember pretty much the exact circumstances in which I saw most films for the first time. As a result, if the circumstances were good then the memory of seeing that film is a positive one. The movies of the 80s, during my teenaged years, hold particular significance. 'Back to the Future' is on my list too. Another comfort film for me is 'Roxanne' since I clearly recall the stroll back home on a beautiful summer's evening, without a care in the world and in the company of my best friend.

Just last night I saw Tootsie for the first time in years. As soon as the credits began and the music started I was immediately transported back to my youth. The whole experience was very bitter sweet. I enjoyed the film all over again, but was sad to realise that a lot of time had passed since first seeing it and I have far more concerns and responsibilities now.

I never have films on in the background. I always want to give them my full attention. (How is it possible to work with all those screaming Goonies!?) Other films on my nostalgia/comfort list include 'Labyrinth', 'Broadcast News', 'Benny & Joon', 'Ferris Bueller's Day Off', 'Aliens' and 'The Blues Brothers'.

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

Nostalgia

Phil · 1 year ago

Yeah, I don't think I've ever "worked" to movies....but there are certainly films that for one reason or another I'll always stop and watch if they're on, or will in fact give me a certain feeling of "nostalgia" when watching...I often like to go to sleep with the TV on and I find there are certain movies I enjoy "listening" to in the background.

Just a few off the top of my head...'Risky Business', 'Empire Strikes Back' (shut up, Jett), 'Rocky', 'The Apartment', 'Goodfellas', 'Field of Dreams'.....

Not necessarily "these are my favorites" - just a few movies I can drop in and watch at any given time..

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

When I worked at a video store whenever Robocop was one we'd just stop and watch...that and Apocalypse Now....

kiley · 1 year ago

Old Hollywood Classics

Tom · 1 year ago

Aliens - definitely in my top five, despite plot holes (although the pre-CGI effects still hold incredibly well).

Anyway - 2001 as comedy?! That's new to me. Actually for me 2001 is the total opposite. I first saw it aged 7 at the cinema and it really freaked me out! The Shining is less scary for me than 2001. All those wailing voices every time the monolith appears and that creepy final sequence in the hotel room as he watches himself become older. The film still spooks me big time today. My wife just found it over long when I showed it to her, so maybe it was the circumstances under which I first saw it that has left me with this reaction. How do the rest of you feel?

I was going to mention this after seeing the Kubrick doc that Jett kindly posted, that I find all of the Kubrick films I've seen (2001 onwards) strangely unnerving to a greater or lesser extent.

Phil · 1 year ago

I consider Wizard of Oz to be a film that spooks me. It was on TNT about a week ago or so, and I had a funny conversation w/ my wife:

Me: This movie always gave me a bit of the creeps.
Wife: You mean when you were a kid? What about today?
Me: I think it's spookier to me now than it was when I was a kid.
Wife: Because of the witch?
Me: No, because of the scarecrow, lion, and tin man.
Wife: What? They're not scary!
Me: Have you ever taken a good look at them? They're hideous!
Wife: I prefer to look at their inner soul.....

kiley · 1 year ago

Nothing But Trouble.

Scariest. Movie. Ever.

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

Comedy in 2001

Tom · 1 year ago

Point taken Jett - still doesn't make me feel any better about the scary wailing voices!!!

Phil - I get the impression that Oz fears are fairly common, probably (like me with 2001) because it's often seen by kids at a very young and impressionable age. Mind you, lots of folks also think the sequel Return to Oz is creepy too!

Kiley - Nothing But Trouble, is that the one with Dan Ackroyd in a weird fat suit?

kiley · 1 year ago

yes! and john candy as a mute woman (he was actually kinda pretty)! i still have nightmares, i tells ya! (most from when dan ackroyd eats the sasauge....oh man...i'm getting creeped out all over again! :P )

Phil · 1 year ago

Also strange for the casting...Demi Moore??

Weird movie, indeed.

Jett Loe · 1 year ago

Groundhog Day

Tom · 1 year ago

Yes, Groundhog Day is definitely there on the comfort film list for me (and others) too. Your mention of it also ties in quite neatly with something i was going to bring up. We have collective comfort films in our family, or rather films that we have all seen so many times that we can quote endlessly to each other. Particular phrases enter our family's vocabulary. For example a cry of 'It's Groundhog Day!' usually accompanies any moment of deja vu we might experience.

Our other adopted films include So I Married An Axe Murderer : 'Heed Move! Will you look at the size of that cranium? It's like a virtual planetoid!' 'She smelt of soup' ect, Life of Brian (too many quotes to mention), While You Were Sleeping: 'You're cheating on a vegetable.' Benny & Joon:" 'You're out of your tree' 'It's not my tree' " And additionally numerous bits of dialogue from Friends.

As mentioned before, it's got nothing to do with the quality of the films.

Gosh yes - definitely do a Groundhog Show Jett. I think as time goes on there seems to be more and more a case for you guys discussing topics like these on the show and talking about old stuff as well as new.

kiley · 1 year ago

ach! good point about about family movie quotes! i definitely grew up quoting and being quoted at all things monty python and the princess bride - and the last job i had everyone went around quoting 'labyrinth' - a little TOO much if ya ask me ;)

Groundhog day works and it always strikes me about how versatile bill murray is - i mean, he's not typical hollywood type. In fact, he's like...well, his face looks like a road map to midgard but there are times he can play some smarmy bastards that have a really strange magnetism LOL